About Us

• Oh What a Bagel! is proud to offer Jersey Shore's best breakfast sandwiches and bagels. Our made-fresh, never frozen bagels are 40% larger than local competitors, we know that you will fall in love after the first bite! Open 365 days a year at our Bayville and Toms River locations, we create handcrafted bagels that are bigger and better! We don't just make amazing breakfast sandwiches, we also have great options for lunch! Stop in today!