Island Club Rentals Homes is one of the highest recommended rental home service in the Put-In-Bay area. If you’d like to skip the hotel experience, you’ll be sure to find yourself ‘at home’ in one of Island Club’s accommodating vacation homes. They each come fully furnished with central air, full kitchens, two bathrooms, private decks, propane grills and many other amenities. The Put-in-Bay Island Club Rentals offers 73 three and four bedroom homes in total, so your options are endless.